Skip the shipping—ask your favorite store to stock us! Order easily via Fortune Fish & Gourmet!

Oven: Roasted Garam Masala Butternut Squash

November 02, 2023

Oven: Roasted Garam Masala Butternut Squash
garam masala butternut squash

THERE IS NOTHING, NOTHING, MORE DELICIOUS THAN ROASTED BUTTERNUT SQUASH.

But there is nothing, nothing more daunting than prepping it when you bring it home. This holiday season I was determined to overcome my inner fears and start playing around with these delicious gourds from prep to bake to incorporating them into delicious recipes.

When prepping, there are a few guidelines I like to follow. I go with a medium-size gourd and slice it into 4 pieces with a large chef's knife. First, I slice it in half (across the middle NOT lengthwise), trim the ends on both sides, and then slice the two pieces in half down the middle. I scoop out the seeds with a small spoon — a grapefruit spoon works really well. And then I start peeling. NOT with a paring knife, but with an ordinary potato peeler. The skin is oddly thin and easy to peel. Another option (a tip from a reader) is to keep the skin on. I tried it and they were right, you can actually cook it and eat it for extra fiber and nutrition — much like the skin on a baked potato.

For me, I prefer to peel half the squash, and keep the skin on the other half. It gives me a good mix of both textures and does not overdo the peel. If cooking and eating the skin, then opt for organic squash. The recipe below gives you a baked version with a garam masala spice blend. If you would like to make it more traditionally, swap out the garam masala for a teaspoon of black pepper. Keep the rest of the recipe the same. This version is perfect to add to an Italian risotto.  

xoxo Anupy

Oven: Roasted Garam Masala Butternut Squash

Prep: 10-15 minutes
Cook: 35-40 minutes
Total: 45-55 minutes
Makes: 4-6 servings

Ingredients

  • 1 medium butternut squash, prepped and cubed (about 7 cups)
  • 1 tablespoon olive oil
  • 2 teaspoons Indian As Apple Pie garam masala 
  • 1 teaspoon salt
  • 2 teaspoons brown sugar

Instructions

  1. Preheat oven to 400°F. 
  2. Place the squash, oil, garam masala, salt, and sugar in a deep bowl and stir until all the pieces are evenly coated. 
  3. Pour the seasoned squash onto a baking tray. Scrape out the remaining oil-spices from the bowl and add to the tray. 
  4. Cook for 35 to 40 minutes until soft and caramelized. Pull out the tray and stir the pieces after 20 minutes for even cooking. Some ovens run hot, so watch towards the end so you don't overcook. My oven took a full 40 minutes to get to the correct consistency, but my mother's oven took 35 minutes. Once cooked to perfection, remove from the oven and enjoy warm. 

Notes

How does it taste? Here's a review from one young taste tester. "Thank you very much for the butternut squash! The texture was very soft and buttery and reminded me very strongly of pumpkin pie. The squash tasted very good, and I would recommend adding a small amount of less salt to some of the pieces. Overall, the flavors combined together really well, and I would look forward to eating this as a dessert."

This from Alexandria C. My mother's neighbor's daughter who is not only a budding foodie, but a balanced taste tester. She's right. When you are mixing the spices and salt you want all the pieces to be coated evenly — in my rush I may have overlooked doing that. Thank you, Alexandria. You and your family rock! Thanks for giving my recipe a try and being an official taste tester for Indian As Apple Pie. 

Watch how easy it is to peel!

"What in the world is this code below?!"

If you’re subscribed to our weekly emails, you’ve probably noticed a block of code pop up under our latest recipes. On the blog, that’s actually a super handy printable/downloadable recipe — but it doesn’t display correctly in email (ahhh, technology!). Click through to our website to access this feature, and rest assured — there’s a method to our madness!

[[ recipeID=recipe-2mh0w2v3c, title=Oven: Roasted Garam Masala Butternut Squash ]]


Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.


Also in Indian As Apple Pie Recipes

Thanksgiving Day 2025 Round Up: Indian-Inspired Recipes and Beyond
Thanksgiving Day 2025 Round Up: Indian-Inspired Recipes and Beyond

November 20, 2025

Continue Reading

Oven: Roasted Garam Masala Brussels Sprouts
Oven: Roasted Garam Masala Brussels Sprouts

November 14, 2025

Continue Reading

Oven: Chai Masala Candied Pecans
Oven: Chai Masala Candied Pecans

November 06, 2025 1 Comment

Continue Reading

Oven: Roasted Garam Masala Butternut Squash

by Anupy Singla, Indian As Apple Pie

Servings: 4

Keywords: Indian Recipes, garam masala, indian spices, indian side, thanksgiving side

  • Prep Time: 10 mins
  • Cook Time: 35 mins
  • Total Time: 45 mins

Ingredients

Instructions

Ingredients

  • 1 medium butternut squash, prepped and cubed (about 7 cups)
  • 1 tablespoon olive oil
  • 2 teaspoons Indian As Apple Pie garam masala
  • 1 teaspoon salt
  • 2 teaspoons brown sugar

Instructions

  1. Preheat oven to 400°F.
  2. Place the squash, oil, garam masala, salt, and sugar in a deep bowl and stir until all the pieces are evenly coated.
  3. Pour the seasoned squash onto a baking tray. Scrape out the remaining oil-spices from the bowl and add to the tray.
  4. Cook for 35 to 40 minutes until soft and caramelized. Pull out the tray and stir the pieces after 20 minutes for even cooking. Some ovens run hot, so watch towards the end so you don't overcook. My oven took a full 40 minutes to get to the correct consistency, but my mother's oven took 35 minutes. Once cooked to perfection, remove from the oven and enjoy warm.

Notes

Thanks for sharing our website with your friends and family!